Website Critique - All Views Welcomed
Hurst,
I agree with Justin on all of his comments and would like to add one. I really liked the contact us/map flash animation you used. Very Nice. Speed was fine. The only thing I would change would be to add some more colors.
John
interwovendesign.com
Quality web site design without the monthly maintenance fees!
Megan posted this at 05:10 — 10th February 2000.
She has: 11,421 posts
Joined: Jun 1999
Is there a really good reason why you're using frames? You've also got a couple of problems with them in there - I clicked on "What our clients say about us", then "continued" and that took me out of the frameset. Without the frameset there is no way of navigating the site. All of your "back to the home page" links on the other pages seem to be breaking the frameset too. Personally, I think frames are more trouble than they're worth, especially since the same thing could be accomplished with a tabled layout.
I also think that you've gone a little too far with the flash. Looping animation is annoying whether it's done with Flash or old fashioned gif's. The opening animation is nice, and so is the one on the main page, but I don't think that should loop - there's already enough going on with the fancy mouseovers
The menu looks pretty good, although I'm not too sure about your use of the purple. It kind of surprised me because it's not used on the rest of the page at all. I wouldn't have put it with pale green, but it doesn't look too bad. Maybe a more bluey-purple would look better.
ON the "News and Forthcoming Events" page you're using a bluey-green that isn't the same as the pale green on the navigation menu - I'd change that to match, change the blue text to green, and the default blue links to something else as well.
One more thing - for a business like this I think you should make sure that your geographical context is known to your visitors before they get too far into the site.
Megan
Connect with us on Facebook!
hurst posted this at 15:18 — 10th February 2000.
They have: 2 posts
Joined: Feb 2000
I would appreciate all views on our website. I would especially appreciate your comments on speed , looks , content and improvements. Thank you for your interest. www.hurst.co.uk
------------------
The views expressed in this message are personal, except where specifically stated
to be of HURST. This message has been transmitted over a public network
and HURST accepts no responsibility for its completeness or accuracy.
Check our website at www.hurst.co.uk
The views expressed in this message are personal, except where specifically stated
to be of HURST. This message has been transmitted over a public network
and HURST accepts no responsibility for its completeness or accuracy.
Check our website at www.hurst.co.uk
Justin S posted this at 15:36 — 10th February 2000.
They have: 2,076 posts
Joined: Jun 1999
Excellent! I really like how you used Flash! Here are a few comments:
Wow!
------------------
The fireburn.com Network:
Justin Stayton - [email] [icq]
Rayna posted this at 16:17 — 10th February 2000.
They have: 115 posts
Joined: Feb 2000
hurst.....
YIKES....at 800 x 600 res there are some problems. I took a screenshot so you can see what I see.
http://www.tripleorbit.com/hurst.jpg
I think you have some great things going on here but honestly if I was a customer surfing the web for services such as yours I would have hit the back button the second I saw all those frames!!
------------------
Rayna
Triple Orbit
Malte posted this at 18:51 — 10th February 2000.
They have: 297 posts
Joined: Apr 1999
You need a scolling=no in the left frame, so the ugly scroll bar disappears.
Malte
Denmark 3 posted this at 23:43 — 10th February 2000.
They have: 881 posts
Joined: Feb 2000
Very good! It is 2 wide on 800 x 600 res.
I don't understand why you have the frame at the bottom either. It is empty and isn't doing anything so why don't you get rid of it? Other than that it is very nice. I just think the colors are kind of ugly.
------------------
~Parker Trasborg~
Formerly- ParkerT and sixflags111
Suzanne posted this at 06:34 — 11th February 2000.
She has: 5,507 posts
Joined: Feb 2000
If you make the frames no scroll, you may have problems at lower resolutions (I didn't look at your code) -- setting the html file to having no margins may resolve part of your problems or adjusting the absolute width of the frame by a few pixels, depending on how you want to resolve it.
Since you have scrolls on both main frame sections, removing the scroll option will present a serious concern for those using a different resolution (smaller) than you are.
It seems to be a lot of advertising and hype on the first two screens with many whirling bits. The colours don't bother me.
Sorry, clicked on a link -- that purple with that green bothers me.
Actually, while it seems to be reasonably laid out navigationally, I still found it to be difficult to navigate because all the images look the same.
You have no text links. While some here seem to think that this isn't an issue, when you are dealing with a professional commercial site, not having text links can mean death for useability and a loss of customers.
Additionally, almost all your inner pages scroll horizontally at my resolution. At last measure, 800X600 was still the most common resolution.
Lastly, even Macromedia uses text links.
It looks like a brochure and fails for useability.
Suzanne
------------------
Zero Cattle
Suzanne
Tables DeMystified
Want to join the discussion? Create an account or log in if you already have one. Joining is fast, free and painless! We’ll even whisk you back here when you’ve finished.