Review for a one-page gift shop site
Dear moderator(s)
My appologies for not following the guideline for Subject Line Format. I used a general description instead of the url or the title. Please reference this past forum thread to see why I request TWF to adjust the posted guidelines to allow a brief subject description in addition to the current url or title requirement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now on to the review. It's a one page site with no links so I'm not really sure why I'm bothering with a review. My client said "make my site look like this other site" so I was tied into the general concept of a swish on the left, a floating list of items next to that, and a slideshow in main area surrounded by text. They wrote the text too so basically, it's just a general thumbs up or thumbs down, especially on the header graphic and color scheme (my wife doesn't like the colors I chose).
redirect >> http://tinyurl.com/9cn44
Notes:
1) I know it doesn't validate because of the slide show script I used. Other than that script, I think it should all be good code.
2) I know the slideshow doesn't disolve between images in Firefox but it looks nice in Internet Explorer, which is what the client uses to see her site.
Thanks y'all.
Megan posted this at 15:34 — 14th July 2005.
She has: 11,421 posts
Joined: Jun 1999
Dont' worry about the title - we just want a way to tell which thread is which. I'll take another look at that agreement right away.
robertlanderson posted this at 23:46 — 14th July 2005.
They have: 14 posts
Joined: Jul 2005
This is my first post on this site.
Anyway, I think that your site is appealing and well layed out.
However, why just one page? For example, I think the items on the left should be links to learn a bit more information and a photo of the item. I am talking about all of these:
Lampe Berger
Monogrammed Soaps
Collegiate and SC Items
Tyler Candles
Candle Lamps
Great Jewelry
Baby/Bunnies By The Bag
Wedding
Frames
Unique Door Bells
Wine Accessories
Hope this helps.
Robert Anderson
Backend Hosting - The Better Solution for Resellers.
EZ Publishing - We make your online venture a Success.
StreamSend - Permission-based email marketing: The most cost-effective way to build and maintain customer relationships.
fifeclub posted this at 13:30 — 15th July 2005.
He has: 688 posts
Joined: Feb 2001
I absolutely agree 100% but the client still insisted on only one page. Maybe time will change her mind.
Yes, I had a problem with a light blue line showing up in Internet Explorer only. Unless I'm mistaken, that problem should be gone, right? You may not have recognized it because I used different colors (lime green and white header text) and because all the text was Lorum Ipsum at that time. So no, you're not crazy.
demonhale posted this at 04:48 — 15th July 2005.
He has: 3,278 posts
Joined: May 2005
Is it Just ME or I have commented about your site before..???
I think it was posted in a different thread... And helped you fixed the Alignment problem??? (Maybe im wrong; just asking anyway)
BRCI posted this at 14:37 — 15th July 2005.
He has: 26 posts
Joined: Jun 2005
OK ... I know this isn't really a review .... (although your site looks great) ... but that javascript image fade that you are using .... can that be put into a background? For instance ... I have :
<TD style="BACKGROUND-IMAGE: url(<a href="http://www.LifeForceOnlineStore.com/img/bg/bg5.jpg" class="bb-url">http://www.LifeForceOnlineStore.com/img/bg/bg5.jpg</a>); BACKGROUND-REPEAT: no-repeat" align="right">
'and I want the image to constantly change. Do you know if this is possible?
A New Shopping Experience
http://www.wolfrivercountryvillage.com
demonhale posted this at 11:33 — 16th July 2005.
He has: 3,278 posts
Joined: May 2005
Can you post this question to a new thread and specify what you really want to have on your site (what you intend to do with the fade effect)
fifeclub posted this at 14:49 — 15th July 2005.
He has: 688 posts
Joined: Feb 2001
That javascript came from dynamicdrive.com . I don't know enough about javascript to write my own code, so I have no idea if that is possible. But I'm sure if you post in the Web Page Authoring category, somebody smarter than me will be able to answer that question for you. (When referencing my site as an example, please use http://tinyurl.com/9cn44 instead of the actual URL)
steve40 posted this at 13:20 — 16th July 2005.
He has: 490 posts
Joined: May 2005
Yes it is possible to do what you want, Dynamic Drive also has some scripts for that. But I really, would not want to fill my page with javascript.
Remember my little photo changing thingy Demon. That can also be used to change an image, you could set time on it up to a day if you wanted, that was a javascript. Really one other reason why I removed it. Also so many people are running around with java disabled in their windows, and the new Windows coming out wont support it why use it.
wwwben posted this at 05:40 — 17th July 2005.
He has: 270 posts
Joined: Jan 2005
Site looks good to me very simple and to the point and very clean...and if it's what the customer wants then it's perfect right?
demonhale posted this at 06:59 — 17th July 2005.
He has: 3,278 posts
Joined: May 2005
Generally you just may have incompatibility when displaying photos, (especially slideshow ones) Thats why photo galleries are derived for that purpose...
1. if you use flash (swf) then theres a greater chance that it wont be viewed by most visitors...
2. Scripts, same as above...
Dont you think so steve?...
Sometimes I sacrifice a front page by using Iframes to show the gallery on the front page (I know plain frames are bad) but iframes as ive experienced is used by many pages... (also double head and body tags; they dont care about the code)... Thats why im trying hard to promote standardization, (W3C) is a start...
JeevesBond posted this at 22:04 — 17th July 2005.
He has: 3,956 posts
Joined: Jun 2002
Ok, we know your reasons for the title so no worries there (thanks for the reminder anyway)
It is a shame this site is only one page - wonder why people just refuse our advice sometimes, but whatever. The left side categories really want to be links, I keep wanting to click on them, could something be done with those?
The green is ok, if a little dark and I like the BG pattern, although it doesn't seem to fit with the rest of the design (sweeping curves etc) very well. It seems you're compensating for this by increasing the width of the border, but all this does is mask the effect slightly, not stop it entirely
I'd want a more compact, and scaleable logo, something more along the lines of their sign I can just see in the background. Can you get the font for that? Or even get an image of the sign straight-on and draw around it in Photoshop (sounds extreme but I've had to do this several times in the past).
Overall a good design, but the background and main design clash somewhat, the categories look like a menu and the logo needs work IMO.
Sorry for the somewhat frank opinion, have just written a letter of complaint to my ISP and blood is boiling a little - please don't take it personally
a Padded Cell our articles site!
JeevesBond posted this at 22:07 — 17th July 2005.
He has: 3,956 posts
Joined: Jun 2002
Slide show?! What slide show?
Guess it doesn't work in Opera (version 8.01), or maybe it's this bloomin dialup. Hmmm.
2020-Graphics posted this at 21:17 — 19th July 2005.
He has: 83 posts
Joined: Feb 2005
I like it, very homey feeling. But like said above, I think the site would gather more interest if the products on the left side had links to them with info and examples.
IanD posted this at 01:55 — 20th July 2005.
They have: 222 posts
Joined: Sep 1999
I like the simple look of it, but the yellow in the navbar, green background and light-green don't go together very well, IMO. I think the photo of the store is good, but might look better if it were bigger, or maybe incorporated into the banner/navbar more.
Also, my eye is kind of being pulled to the right too far. Maybe if the navbar width was smaller so that the real content is more centered? I know you'd have to use line breaks, but it might be worth it.
Fighting for a Lost Cause.net
mattbutterworth posted this at 18:44 — 3rd August 2005.
They have: 9 posts
Joined: Aug 2005
The is my first review. Here goes!
Positive
1. Gives a real sense of home craft type goods - nice feel - traditional
2. Not too pushy - if I was in the area I'd drop in
Constructive criticism
1. Links on the left - but they aren't links - I keep clicking them. Have read above posts and understand why now.
2. What about a link to a map e.g. Google maps?
3. An idea. Offer your client the additional pages at no cost and set-up a simple cart system - if the business comes in, split it 50%/50%.
4. Looking at the content, meta tags, page title: would anybody find this website unless they knew where to look? I may be wrong.
Hope that any of this was helpful.
Matt.
diceventures posted this at 06:03 — 6th August 2005.
They have: 40 posts
Joined: Jul 2005
I very much like it. great colours and style
one thing i found bad, was the load time...took over 5 seconds for the page to fully load.
Want to join the discussion? Create an account or log in if you already have one. Joining is fast, free and painless! We’ll even whisk you back here when you’ve finished.