Review- cmon, you know you want to

They have: 17 posts

Joined: Jul 2000

http://www.staindnet.com - some of you may have already seen this on Sitepoint, but I would like a review please, and comment on anything you can think of!

AndyB's picture

They have: 344 posts

Joined: Aug 1999

Just minor things:

If the left margin were set to zero, the navbar would snug up to the left edge of the window and look better.

On most pages, the body background is not black - that means that the edge of the navbar image is quite evident. A black page background would make it 'seamless'.

Someone is sure to comment that the logo/nav is fuzzy. That might be part of the artistic intent, but .. since the logo/nav only loads once, a little extra file size and better image wouldn't hurt.

They have: 472 posts

Joined: Oct 1999

The circular side menu(bar?) looks jagged. Overall, nice design. Smiling

They have: 184 posts

Joined: Jun 2000

[MAN I LOVE THAT LIGHTBULB!]

Couple things:
That navigational panel doesn't look good.
It looks like it holds itself within its own boundries. Remove the leftmost Bevel and it'd look fine.

I can't really see the lettering on the Nav Panel unless I get up close and examine. To draw this out you could possibly add a darker color behind the letters, and blur it up so you get a nice two level effect.

The site design just.. doesn't look good. Like it was all just thrown onto a peice of paper from when I fall asleep drawing in Study Hall.

I'd say just streamline your web sites--that's a matter of personal style so I can't help you there.

Hope that helped.

Mike Fisher
Hypertrophy (design)
[email protected]
ICQ: 38389521
"Taking over TWF, one post at a time."

They have: 5,633 posts

Joined: Jan 1970

Looks great

try setting the page margins to 0

i like the menu bar but make the text a bit more obvious

apart from that it looks great

They have: 17 posts

Joined: Jul 2000

Quote: Originally posted by jackchen
The site design just.. doesn't look good. Like it was all just thrown onto a peice of paper from when I fall asleep drawing in Study Hall.

I'd say just streamline your web sites--that's a matter of personal style so I can't help you there.

I don't quite get it, what do you mean streamline?

They have: 184 posts

Joined: Jun 2000

[WOO! LIGHTBULBY!]

That's me up there!

I mean make them look half organised. Like Yahoo! with its outright organisation, or Screamdesign.com with it's superb artwork, they all have their style.

That's what people want to see in a web site, they want to see originality, eyecandy. What I see here is [forgive my being so short] a run of the mill web site.

Style is what makes or breaks a site.

Mike Fisher
Hypertrophy (design)
[email protected]
ICQ: 38389521
"Taking over TWF, one post at a time."

They have: 17 posts

Joined: Jul 2000

ahhhh, I gotcha. I'll work on it.

Denmark 3's picture

They have: 881 posts

Joined: Feb 2000

It looks very good. Just the left menu is very very blurry and I can't read it at all but thats just about the only thing. Smiling

Brian Farkas's picture

They have: 1,015 posts

Joined: Apr 1999

It doesn't look too bad... Just a few things:

1. Set left margin to 0
2. Make your table width 760 so we do not have to scroll at 800x600
3. Add rollover effects to the nav bar
4. Right now you have the menubar as a JPG. Try breaking it up into smaller images for each button, and save those as a gif. Text looks sharper when saved as a gif, unless you save with a very high quality jpeg, in which case it would take a lot more space.

Brian Farkas

They have: 68 posts

Joined: Jul 1999

Ok I can't read the menu either. Not in the slightest.

Don't like the white moseovers. I occasionally like to see what my mouse is over.

Bottom Links I think should be centered with the page not the cell.

I'm guessing the page will look different with more content. Looks very icky now. Add some random text or somethikng for the time being. Just so we can see what it would lookl like in reality.
I do like the colors.

Don't m,ean to seem harsh, just the nav unreadibility juped at me. I also have trouble visualizing what your going for with the content.

Brian Wilmot

Brian Wilmot
----------------------------
http://www.jumpnow.net/ - Come on take a look! -

"War is a failure of diplomacy and imagination and creativity." Dennis Kucinich

Justin S's picture

They have: 2,076 posts

Joined: Jun 1999

1) I agree about making the left margin 0.

2) The background of the menu/logo is slightly darker then the page background. It would look much better if they were the same shade of grey/black.

3) The menu area is very blurry for me, and the edges are a tiny bit jagged. Try saving the image at the highest quality possible. You also might want to make the menu text a little darker.

4) The page scrolls for me on 800x600 resolution. With no left margins then make the table 780 pixels in width. Then it won't scroll. If you do decide to keep the margins, then make the table width 760.

They have: 17 posts

Joined: Jul 2000

AT the risk of sounding stupid:

how do I change the left margin to zero? I'm pretty sure I never set a margin at all!

Adam

AndyB's picture

They have: 344 posts

Joined: Aug 1999

Sets all margins to zero for IE, NN, and webTV

Want to join the discussion? Create an account or log in if you already have one. Joining is fast, free and painless! We’ll even whisk you back here when you’ve finished.