Echo Homeschool Co-op

He has: 69 posts

Joined: Oct 2003

Can you critique my site I made for a small homeschooling program. The person I told it for wanted mostly shades of purple and blue, and wanted it to look a little childish. The only subpages I have up right now are the tag us, and contact.. so I just want critique on the homepage.

oops forgot link.. echoschool.com

They have: 10 posts

Joined: Jul 2004

Using Win XP Pro, Mozilla 1.7, cable connection.

I got 5 sec. delay on the main picture in the middle and the side (blue) wave. The picture in the middle blinks on reload AND on picture change.

Hope this helps! Smiling

He has: 69 posts

Joined: Oct 2003

sp_100 wrote: Using Win XP Pro, Mozilla 1.7, cable connection.

I got 5 sec. delay on the main picture in the middle and the side (blue) wave. The picture in the middle blinks on reload AND on picture change.

Hope this helps! Smiling

Yeah, I guess that's because it had to load all of the pictures (there's 8 in all). I'm not sure why the wave thing took a while. The blinking at reload doesn't happen on IE. I use firefox, so I see what you were talking about, but I don't know a script that fades smoothly in all browsers. I can probably take off some of the dark pictures to make it load faster.

Megan's picture

She has: 11,421 posts

Joined: Jun 1999

Looks pretty good. I like the rotating pictures in the middle. A few of them are sort of dark though.

The first thing I was drawn to was the title on the right side. It's sort of funny looking. I think you've gone too casual with the lower font. The size change in the main title is a little odd too. Then I glanced over to the left side and saw the logo there. That's a great logo, but it's hidden in the corner there by itself. Find a way to make that more pominent, either by making it bigger or moving it out of the box you've got it in.

I do like those lines of varying widths across the page. I like how you've broken from the straight line, 90 degree lines normally used in web design.

More font conflicts are occuring futher down with the page header. You've got a very formal script in the background and a crisp sans in the foreground. It's generally a good idea not to use too many specialty fonts within a design. Espeically when it comes to really decorative fonts like the one you have in the logo and the welcome background.

I've just noticed the lightly textured background on the outer edges. That's a nice touch.

He has: 69 posts

Joined: Oct 2003

Megan wrote: Looks pretty good. I like the rotating pictures in the middle. A few of them are sort of dark though.

The first thing I was drawn to was the title on the right side. It's sort of funny looking. I think you've gone too casual with the lower font. The size change in the main title is a little odd too. Then I glanced over to the left side and saw the logo there. That's a great logo, but it's hidden in the corner there by itself. Find a way to make that more pominent, either by making it bigger or moving it out of the box you've got it in.

I do like those lines of varying widths across the page. I like how you've broken from the straight line, 90 degree lines normally used in web design.

More font conflicts are occuring futher down with the page header. You've got a very formal script in the background and a crisp sans in the foreground. It's generally a good idea not to use too many specialty fonts within a design. Espeically when it comes to really decorative fonts like the one you have in the logo and the welcome background.

I've just noticed the lightly textured background on the outer edges. That's a nice touch.

Thanks for such a detailed critique. I'm going to get rid of some of the darker pictures to hopefully increase load time. I couldn't decide whether to keep the "odd" size change in the title or not. Then I thought, that the person I was making it for wanted it a little childish, so I just kept it. I will edit that image and save it and see which one looks better. The font I used may be too casual, but it is actually less casual than what the person wanted originally. The welcome image I didn't make for that site, I did it for another site I had made (http://www.koa.planetubh.com/e/), and I just liked it so I added it to this site. You are probably right about having too many specialty fonts though.

Thanks

They have: 42 posts

Joined: Jun 2004

Nice and original design. Colors and (dolphin) theme works well together. Links could be made with images, right now they are a bit boring.

-Teemu

He has: 69 posts

Joined: Oct 2003

Temudzin wrote: Nice and original design. Colors and (dolphin) theme works well together. Links could be made with images, right now they are a bit boring.

-Teemu

I thought links made w/ images was a bad thing. Confused

davidjaymz's picture

He has: 193 posts

Joined: Jul 2001

I'd agree with links made with images being a bad thing. but CSS is another matter... You can pretty up those links quickly with some CSS.

Overall i like the site, on some pages the blue wave just stops rather than going all the way to the bottom of the page.
Also the page not having a "bottom" per se. I'm not sure if i like that? Maybe i'm too ordered in my thinking. lol.

Can the Nav bar blue be pulled across so it meets the Darker Line blue all the way down the page? it looks a bit odd with the straight line some white then the slanted blue.

Hope /some/ of this is helpful

He has: 69 posts

Joined: Oct 2003

davidjaymz wrote: I'd agree with links made with images being a bad thing. but CSS is another matter... You can pretty up those links quickly with some CSS.

Overall i like the site, on some pages the blue wave just stops rather than going all the way to the bottom of the page.
Also the page not having a "bottom" per se. I'm not sure if i like that? Maybe i'm too ordered in my thinking. lol.

Can the Nav bar blue be pulled across so it meets the Darker Line blue all the way down the page? it looks a bit odd with the straight line some white then the slanted blue.

Hope /some/ of this is helpful

I actually did use CSS for the links, apparently I didn't dress them up enogh Sticking out tongue. Yeah I was planning on adding some sort of bottom eventually, I just haven't got around to it yet. I kinda like the nave bard seperate from that darker line.. :\ even though it may be odd. Sticking out tongue

Thanks for the suggestions. Smiling

Want to join the discussion? Create an account or log in if you already have one. Joining is fast, free and painless! We’ll even whisk you back here when you’ve finished.