Bogus Link Exchange Requests
Greetings:
I got a request for link exchange; to add a link to a site that is compatible with my site. I added it. The next day I got an email stating that my link had been added, not to the site I linked to, but to what I will call a link farm ([url]http://onemission.com/Internet/WWW/WebPortals/)[/url].
I've removed their link from my site and asked them to remove mine from theirs.
Is this a new scam?
Jon Shannon
Sierra Nomad Photography
Yosemite Hiking Guide DVD & Trail Maps
JeevesBond posted this at 08:47 — 20th October 2007.
He has: 3,956 posts
Joined: Jun 2002
We always ignore those link exchanges anyway, they tend to be low quality and Google is ignoring link exchanges these days anyway. You might well be right though, it could be a new scam, although I've always thought those e-mail link exchanges were dodgy.
a Padded Cell our articles site!
Sierra Nomad posted this at 14:45 — 20th October 2007.
He has: 50 posts
Joined: Feb 2005
!! Are you saying that even high quality links don't have a bearing on your google ranking?
Megan: Yes, that concerned me, too.
Jon Shannon
Sierra Nomad Photography
Yosemite Hiking Guide DVD & Trail Maps
Megan posted this at 18:02 — 20th October 2007.
She has: 11,421 posts
Joined: Jun 1999
For reciprocals I think it sort of depends. If they are obvious reciprocals (site-wide, or on a page with lots of other links) then they probably aren't worth much. If they seem natural then it might be okay. It is natural for sites to link to each other but not as a traditional "link exchange".
Remember that Google doesn't want to count anything that is not a natural link (editorially given on the basis of merit). So they are going to try to devalue anything that isn't - reciprocals, paid links, anything you may have created yourself (forum signatures etc.)
Megan
Connect with us on Facebook!
Sierra Nomad posted this at 02:57 — 21st October 2007.
He has: 50 posts
Joined: Feb 2005
Wow! That's food for thought. In the past I've spent a lot of time & energy trying to get good links. I was getting ready to do so again, guess I'll have to rethink where to spend my energy. Thanks Megan!
Jon Shannon
Sierra Nomad Photography
Yosemite Hiking Guide DVD & Trail Maps
mandyjb posted this at 04:37 — 21st October 2007.
She has: 164 posts
Joined: Aug 2006
The best thing to do is to exchange links (not too many) with sites that have the same theme as your site. I get a lot of link exchange offers by email from sites that do not even compare to my sites theme. I also get a lot of these three way linking offers which i always ignore. I am very picky about who i exchange links with and i always keep a record of the sites i exchange with. These are checked weekly, and if i find my link not present on their site then their link is automatically deleted. I find that some sites, offer a link exchange (theme relevant) and within a week they have deleted my link for one reason. I have a link page rank 3 and they have 0. They want a one way link from a ranked link page to boost their ranking. I find this quite often. Their link is obviously deleted immediately. Don't get caught out. I once emailed a site that had done this, i got the reply, i am sorry, i have too many links and i can not keep count. You must monitor your links so that sites with loads and loads of links do not keep up this cheat. A links page with a few relevant links is better than a links page or directory with links that do not even have the same theme as your site.
I have come across link pages that have four or five relevant links on with a page rank 4 or 5 as opposed to a page with lots of links on that has a page rank 0.
Monitor your links and be choosy!
Megan posted this at 13:43 — 21st October 2007.
She has: 11,421 posts
Joined: Jun 1999
You do need good links just not exchanged links (or bought links, or links you put there yourself).
I do think there is value in creating a real partnership between sites where you link to each other more heavily. We have noticed a beneift in our three sites being strongly tied to each other (TWF, A Padded Cell, and my blog). But this is more than a link exchange it's a strong connection with frequent linking back and forth.
Megan
Connect with us on Facebook!
Sierra Nomad posted this at 10:58 — 22nd October 2007.
He has: 50 posts
Joined: Feb 2005
Thank you both for the tips.
Jon
Jon Shannon
Sierra Nomad Photography
Yosemite Hiking Guide DVD & Trail Maps
Megan posted this at 13:13 — 20th October 2007.
She has: 11,421 posts
Joined: Jun 1999
What he said
The other thing you should be concerned about is that these sites aren't connected to bad neighbourhoods (spam, porn etc.). If they are your site could be penalized for being connected to them.
Megan
Connect with us on Facebook!
Want to join the discussion? Create an account or log in if you already have one. Joining is fast, free and painless! We’ll even whisk you back here when you’ve finished.