is Mollom really that good?
I recently updated a couple site to Drupal 6 and came to the part where I needed to fight spam and I became quite despondent as I looked at what was available. Or wasn't. Or what won't be.
First of, I don't want to use those stupid CAPTCHA thingys. I hate them. They're annoying.
In Drupal 6 we seem to have these options: spam.module, akismet.module and Mollom.
spam.module didn't seem to work at all.
akismet.module says it's not supported anymore. (I actually really liked this on my Drupal 5 installs.)
Then there's the Mollom thing. I have it installed, and I think it works, mostly. But I have no idea if any real comments are getting blocked.
With akismet, you have a list of the spam posts to breeze through to see if something was 'misplaced.'
So is anyone using Mollom and finding it to be decent? Am I just over thinking things?
~silverwing
decibel.places posted this at 03:37 — 14th February 2009.
He has: 1,494 posts
Joined: Jun 2008
Doesn't Mollom include captcha?
I use the captcha modules, on non-Drupal sites I use reCAPTCHA which is a little more elegant than the Drupal ones. (Drupal reCAPTCHA module)
Sometimes on HTML forms I just put a mouseover on the submit button test, I know that is not foolproof but eliminates about 80% of spam, on my old GeoCities site.
I too have been curious about Mollom so please keep us posted.
@silverwing - haven't seen you around for a while, how are things?
silverwing posted this at 19:26 — 14th February 2009.
He has: 79 posts
Joined: May 2008
Like Megan said, it does use a captcha if Mollom isn't really sure it's spam. Which I think is a deterrent. If you have a captcha on the comment form, the commenter knows that. But if it magically appears after you click submit, it may be a turn-off to submit your comment.
I guess my real problem here is that Drupal is about choice. You've generally got a dozen ways to do something. Except deal with spam.
I've been taking a bit of an internet sabbatical - not being a full-time internet
loserjunkie. A mental health holiday of sorts! But I'm back now.zinzinny | Misguided Thoughts | showcaseCMS
Megan posted this at 18:58 — 14th February 2009.
She has: 11,421 posts
Joined: Jun 1999
I've been using Mollom for a couple of months on one relatively low traffic site. I guess you just have to trust that it's not blocking out any real comments. It is supposed to show the captcha if it's unsure.
I really wish they would show you a list of posts - it's just a peace of mind thing to be sure that it's doing what it's supposed to.
Megan
Connect with us on Facebook!
silverwing posted this at 19:30 — 14th February 2009.
He has: 79 posts
Joined: May 2008
There is something of a log on your site. Go to admin/reports/dblog and filter for Mollom. Not as nice as Akismet, but it's there.
And I'd rather spend a few minutes going through my akismet spam log to see if anything got caught that shouldn't have been than wondering if someone just gave up.
It's about control. It's my site, and I want to decide what goes on in it!
~silverwing
zinzinny | Misguided Thoughts | showcaseCMS
decibel.places posted this at 03:25 — 26th March 2009.
He has: 1,494 posts
Joined: Jun 2008
I am using Mollom which is part of an installation profile (Open Publish)
The free version permits up to 100 posts per day, the premium version is 30€ per month
Want to join the discussion? Create an account or log in if you already have one. Joining is fast, free and painless! We’ll even whisk you back here when you’ve finished.