who's holding my domain?

They have: 304 posts

Joined: Dec 1999

Hello everyone,
I'm in a bit of a domain/host mess and hoped maybe one of you can advise. It's a longish story so I'll hope you'll bear with me...
I have a web site about cats in Hebrew and my domain is "shoonra.com". My brother-in-law is the person who actually owns the domain, as he bought it on my behalf when I was new to the business (he wanted to encourage me to start my own site). He also paid for my web host for the first months (up till now) through his company. He used "1st Choice" hosting services. My only connection with them was uploading the site. I had nothing to do with the financial side and all was well.
A few weeks ago, my brother-in-law told me that he was leaving his company (giving up his share in management) and suggested that I'll take care of the hosting from now own as the company would stop paying for hosting my site. I started looking for a host and checked "1stchoice" as well as others. I found some better deals and decided to move to another web host. I chose "Cedant.com" who offered a nice deal + two free weeks for trial.
I uploaded my site to Cedant and asked them to take over my domain.
I've had some technical problems with the upload and discovered that Cedant never replied to any of my pleas for help. It's not that they couldn't e-mail me, because they had no difficulty sending me a request to pay when the 2 weeks were over. since I wish to be able to get support by e-mail, and was very disappointed with their service I decided to look for another host.
While this was going on, my site suddenly went down. I contacted "1stchoice" and they informed me that they weren't paid in time. I told them that I had no idea as I was never involved with paying and that I was about to move my site. I asked my brother-in-law and he claims that they did pay, but that there are internal problems in "1stchoice". I have absolutely no way to find out who's right.
Well... on to another host...
This time I went to WestHost. Since I was about to leave for a 2-weeks holiday I hurried and registered with them, set up my account, paid in advance and uploaded my site. Since they asked, I sent an e-mail to both "Cedant" and "1stchoice", asking them to change my domain's server setting.

I came back from my holiday yesterday and found out that the site was totally down. No e-mail account and no nothing (you can check for yourself at [url=http://www.shoonra.com).]www.shoonra.com).[/url]

Does any one have a clue as to what's going on? I sent an e-mail to Westhost of course, but I was just wondering if any of you can help me out. How can I find out which company actually holds my domain? Can "1stchoice" hold it against my will until someone pays up? What am I to do?
Sorry for the long story...
By the way, should anyone wish to e-mail me, I am temporarily using my isp account and the address is: [email protected]
Thanks!

They have: 5,633 posts

Joined: Jan 1970

code:

Registrant:
K. Vision system solutions LTD. (SHOONRA-DOM)
   Meshek1
   Netaim, Israel 76870
   IL

   Domain Name: SHOONRA.COM

   Administrative Contact, Technical Contact, Zone Contact:
      Company Administration  (SF232-ORG)  [email protected]
      1st Choice International Holdings Inc
      265 Klassen Road
      Kelowna, BC V1X7P1
      CA
      250-491-9386
      Fax- 250-491-5644
   Billing Contact:
      Mosenzon, Ofer  (OMX5)  [email protected]
      K. Vision system solutions LTD.
      Meshek1
      Netaim, Israel 76870
      IL
      +972 3 9666920 (FAX) +972 3 9581098

   Record last updated on 21-Sep-1999.
   Record expires on 21-Sep-2001.
   Record created on 21-Sep-1999.
   Database last updated on 1-May-2000 03:33:09 EDT.

   Domain servers in listed order:

   NS1.1STCHOICE-UN.NET		216.15.209.2
   NS2.1STCHOICE-UN.NET		216.15.209.3
[/code]

Basically, that says a couple things:

1) The domain is still pointing at 1stchoice's servers which is why it is down.
2) K. Vision system solutions LTD. owns the domain. Now, unless this is you, this could be a very big problem.
3) Your domain hasn't been moved thus far because [email protected] has not authorized it, or at least, that is what I suspect. It isn't that Cedant *didn't* try to move the domain but it is that they *couldn't* - This doesn't make up for not contacting you explaining the situation, of course. This is your old host and they are basically holding your domain hostage. 

You are in a really *big* bind here as from what I can see, you have absolutely no controlling power over this domain. You basically don't own this domain and you have nothing to do with it so unless you can get 1stchoice or K. Vision system solutions LTD. to work with you, you can't do much except let the site die. If K. Vision system solutions LTD. is willing to transfer the domain to you, than you will be OK ... You will have to contact them about that.

You are in the worst position that I have seen for a domain name. I would suggest that you contact WestHost and ask them to help you out in trying to transfer ownership of your domain to you - hopefully they would be willing to do so but they aren't obligated to. As for making your domain work until the domain is in your hands, this isn't likely. Since 1stchoice shut you down, I doubt they are going to take the needed actions to transfer your domain. Your site is going to remain in limbo forever or until you can transfer the ownership of the domain.

I'm sorry to see that you are in this type of a situation. You have pretty much just lost your domain. Unless K. Vision system solutions LTD. is going to work with you, you might as well search for a new domain.

------------------
TWF Administrator

Dynamic Internet Solutions : Windows NT and UNIX Hosting & Dedicated Servers 

They have: 304 posts

Joined: Dec 1999

Thanks for the help!
I suspect that K. Vision systems is my brother-in-law's company. I'll try and find out if that's him personally or not. If it is there should be no problem getting him to act on my behalf in whichever way needed. I guess that would mean him writing to 1stchoice and telling them to let go of the domain, is that right?
By the way, is it legally possible for a host to hold on to a domain like that? Like you said, it's pretty much a hostage in a financial dispute.
I'd hate to have to find a different domain, as I've managed to build quite a uniqe web identity in Israel. It's a non-comercial site but it has huge success in Israeli terms. It's meant to help cat owners take better care of their cats and has tons of info in Hebrew on the subject. I'm doing it with the help of the Israeli Cat Society which is dedicated to helping cats, esp. ferals and strays. In fact what I'm most proud of is the dozens of cats which my site helped to find good homes for in the short period in which it's been online.
Point is, the domain is a big part of my web identity (it means cat in arameic). It is the site's name and it's got all it's publicity by that name (I got very positive reviews in leading newspapers, national radio and national TV). It would be a shame to let it die and I'll do my best to save it.
Thanks again for your help Chad. I'll let you know how it goes.
Anat.

They have: 5,633 posts

Joined: Jan 1970

You will have to get involved with Network Solutions on this, which isn't fun. Network Solutions is a pain in the butt to work with in these types of situations (as in most complicated situations).

http://www.networksolutions.com

You probably want to visit that URL. They have the information you will need to take on something like this.

Basically, what you will be doing is having K. Vision system solutions LTD. tell them that 1stchoice is not authorized to be the admin, technical, or billing contact, and you will want them to change the contacts to yourself. This will involve K. Vision system solutions LTD. as they are the owners of the domain. Once the contacts are changed, you will be able to change the name servers.

I would recommend that once the domain comes up for renewal in September of 2001, just let it expire and than register it in your own name, instead of K. Vision system solutions LTD.

------------------
TWF Administrator

Dynamic Internet Solutions : Windows NT and UNIX Hosting & Dedicated Servers

They have: 304 posts

Joined: Dec 1999

Hi Chad,
All's well that ends well...
My site is online again. My brother-in-law contacted Network Solutions and they changed the administrative contact so that's also him now.
I'll definitely take up your advice on the renewal.
You can have a look at Shoonra now at www.shoonra.com. It's in Hebrew so your browser will probably show Gibberish, but you can see my cat in the middle!
Thanks again.
Anat.

They have: 5,633 posts

Joined: Jan 1970

Glad to hear you got it settled Anat!!!! I am extremely surprised that Network Solutions worked with you guys that quickly. In my experience with them, it takes at least 2 weeks for them to get moving and another two weeks before any results are seen in these cases.

BTW, your site is in gibberish ... Nice looking site though (and cat).

------------------
TWF Administrator

Dynamic Internet Solutions : Windows NT and UNIX Hosting & Dedicated Servers

They have: 5,633 posts

Joined: Jan 1970

Yeah. That’s not normal. I have a client who’s been trying for over a month to get his administrative contact changed.

------------------
Adam
AIS Internet Solutions
[email protected]
www.aisinternet.com

They have: 359 posts

Joined: Mar 1999

Hey, I almost deciphered it. Decided it kinda looks like my handwriting and then I remembered that I can't read my own handwriting so I gave up!

Dan

Dan
Recycle Video Games Network

Stupidity killed the cat, curiosity was framed!

They have: 1,587 posts

Joined: Mar 1999

i think u'll find a high level of customer service from network solutions as the competition for saling domain names continues to increase while ns continue to charge outrageous fees.

------------------
CLICK 4 some tested resources for making money $, hosting, and web promotions.
My Site got hacked, but i'm coming back?

Traffic-Website.com free traffic, affiliate programs, hosting, & domain names.
My Site got hacked, but i'm coming back?

They have: 74 posts

Joined: Apr 2000

Anat,
Yours is the first Hebrew site I have visited. Never thought about it until now, but the "Standard" for Hebrew sites is probably to have the nav bar on the right as opposed to the left with English language sites, correct?

They have: 453 posts

Joined: Jan 1999

Hi,

I had a similar problem 2 years ago.
A big german provider held my domain webhome.de hostage for around 16 month.

I have it back, but it gave the lawyers quite a bit of work.

Luckily it looks like the process is being changed so that the admin-c can override the tech-c

[This message has been edited by anti (edited 12 May 2000).]

Want to join the discussion? Create an account or log in if you already have one. Joining is fast, free and painless! We’ll even whisk you back here when you’ve finished.